DIY Condiments: Our Favorite Ketchup, Mayo, BBQ, and Mustard Recipes

Last Updated February 24, 2018
Share to printerest Share to fb Share to twitter Share to mail Share to print
DIY condiment recipes - homemade mayonnaise, homemade ketchup, homemade mustard, homemade hot sauce

See how easy it is to make ketchup, mayonnaise, hot sauce, mustard, BBQ sauce, and more. You'll never go store-bought again, and your version will probably be healthier.

DIY Spicy-Sweet Ketchup

This super-easy, fiery ketchup will make you wonder why you ever thought the bottled stuff would do.

Blueberry Ketchup

blueberry ketchup
Try this condiment and you’ll be surprised at how well the berries clear the savory line. I love it on burgers. It’s not too sweet and it’s laced with the same spices found in the classic...

Homemade Vegan Mayonnaise

This creamy, vegan "mayonnaise" is wonderful on sandwiches and in bound salads. Add spices like yellow curry powder or lemon pepper for unique variations.

Homemade Mayonnaise

Fresh mayo has a ton of flavor and takes only minutes to make. Add fresh herbs, piquant spices, or minced garlic for delicious variations.

DIY Mustard

Long before you could buy mustard in a snazzy array of sophisticated flavors, fourth-century Romans were glazing spit-roasted boars with the aromatic, gritty paste. The seed is found on every...

Five-Spice Mustard

Hot! Ground spices can replace the whole ones in this no-vinegar blend. Mixed with soy sauce and honey, it makes a great dip for Chinese dumplings. Three or four tablespoons in a pound of ground meat...

Apple Butter BBQ Sauce

Enough for approximately 2-3 pounds of pulled pork.

Blueberry Chipotle BBQ Sauce

blueberry chipotle BBQ sauce
This is the type of sauce that gives the barbecue purists fits, but it has humble origins, even if it ended up being kind of a big deal. Our original owner, Tom, once made this sauce for a dinner...

Datil Pepper Hot Sauce

Jar of datil pepper sauce
Living in Northeast Florida, you probably know someone with a recipe for datil pepper sauce. But this is Pat Hamilton's Datil Pepper Sauce! The majority of datil peppers grown in the U.S. are produced...

Xanadu Pepper Sauce

Inspired by the slightly gummy, translucent red Thai sweet chili sauce found in local Asian supermarkets.

Spicy Buffalo Wing Sauce

Spicy Buffalo Wing Sauce
Heat ’em up with a spicy Buffalo wing sauce: All your tailgater friends have to do is add chicken wings. This versatile sauce can also perk up a grilled chicken breast sandwich.
Build your own subscription bundle.
Pick 3 regions for $60
We will never share your email address with anyone else. See our privacy policy.